« Column 116 | Main | Want to revive the Cold and abandon the Long? »

Traditional walls inevitably come down

ARTICLE: Arab auds unfazed by Saudi fatwa, Variety, Aug. 1, 2008

One of the reasons why I don't worry about efforts at cultural censorship in more traditional societies is that those walls inevitably come down, largely in response to popular demands -- if the connectivity is achieved and average people get a taste. That's often a generational affair: the first generation of connectivity is harshly condemned and restricted (and frankly, the surfeit of pornography should be), but for those growing up inside that first generation (the second), the demand for more freedom inevitably ensues. The "walled garden" just isn't enough. They sense the Matrix's walls.

And the youngest and most adventuresome will take just about any "red pill" you offer.

So I say to the Googles and Microsofts of the world, cut any deal you must to get the connectivity laid down. Orwell continues to be wrong. The kids will end up being more than "all right."

This conflict's outcome was never in doubt, just our tendency to freak out unnecessarily.

(Thanks: Dan Hare)

Comments (4)

Orwell's got the Gap right.

"Orwell continues to be wrong. The kids will end up being more than "all right."

There's more than a few, more than "a most", people in England that would disagree with you. Even Pete Townshend.

vanderleun,

shocked to hear that, friend. what? cynicism in britainia? it just can't be. defeatists in englandia, no! i, for one, am thankful for the pushback. and am especially looking forward to the inevitable confrontations with mr hitchens and mr sullivan some time this coming february. i'll be more than ready, will you?

Reminds me of the "opening" of China and the lead-up to the Opium Wars.

In fact, what is happening in the Middle East today seems to resemble what occurred in China in the 19th Century.

And, one might say, things for the kids in 19th and 20th Century China (before Deng) did not turn out too well.

Post a comment

Comments must adhere to the comment policy. All TypeKey comments will post immediately (but are still subject to moderation) All other comments must wait for moderation before they publish. Please also read How to write so Tom will post/reply.

'Development-in-a-Box' is a registered trademark of Enterra Solutions.

Buy Tom's books online









About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on August 25, 2008 6:17 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Column 116.

The next post in this blog is Want to revive the Cold and abandon the Long?.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.31